Finding a reliable, skilled painter can be the difference between a smooth, professional finish and a frustrating, costly mistake. Whether you’re repainting your home, updating your business, or refinishing a cabin, choosing the right painting contractor matters.
At Black Mountain Painting, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners and business owners across Spearfish, Deadwood, Lead, Sturgis, and Rapid City transform their spaces with lasting, high-quality results. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to find a good painter—written by professionals who know the industry inside and out.
Step 1: Start with Local Referrals and Experience
Finding a reliable, skilled painter can be the difference between a smooth, professional finish and a frustrating, costly mistake. Whether you’re repainting your home, updating your business, or refinishing a cabin, choosing the right painting contractor matters.
At Black Mountain Painting, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners and business owners across Spearfish, Deadwood, Lead, Sturgis, and Rapid City transform their spaces with lasting, high-quality results. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to find a good painter—written by professionals who know the industry inside and out.
Step 2: Check Reviews and Portfolios Online
Before making calls, research painters online. Check Google, Facebook, and Yelp for reviews and focus on comments about communication, cleanliness, and craftsmanship.
A reputable painter should also have a portfolio of completed projects. Look for before-and-after photos that show attention to detail, smooth finishes, and clean lines—signs of a skilled professional.
Pro Tip: Consistency matters. A good painter will have many high-quality projects that demonstrate expertise in both residential and commercial work.
Step 2: Check Reviews and Portfolios Online
Hiring a painter without proper coverage is risky. Always confirm they have general liability insurance and, if applicable, workers’ compensation insurance. This protects both you and the crew in case of an accident.
Ask if they hold any state or local licenses required for residential or commercial painting. A professional contractor should have no issue showing proof of documentation.
Pro Tip: If a painter hesitates to show insurance or avoids questions about credentials—move on.
Step 4: Get Multiple Written Estimates
Meet with at least two or three painters and ask for written estimates. A detailed quote should include:
-
Scope of work and prep steps
-
Paint brands and number of coats
-
Timeline and estimated completion date
-
Total cost, labor, and materials
Step 5: Ask About Process and Materials
Not all paints or techniques perform the same. Ask about:
-
Paint brands used: Premium paints like Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore last longer in South Dakota’s climate.
-
Preparation steps: Cleaning, sanding, and priming are essential for durability.
-
Environmental conditions: Exterior jobs require attention to temperature, sunlight, and humidity.
In the Black Hills, where weather can be unpredictable, using top-quality materials and proper prep ensures a finish that stands the test of time.
Step 6: Prioritize Professionalism Over Price
While cost matters, the lowest bid often comes with hidden trade-offs. Professional painters invest in training, tools, and safety—delivering results that last for years, not months.
Look for painters who:
-
Show up on time and communicate clearly
-
Maintain clean, organized work areas
-
Provide written warranties or satisfaction guarantees
Step 7: Choose the Painter Who Earns Your Trust
Once you’ve compared estimates, portfolios, and communication styles, go with the contractor who feels right—not just the cheapest. A trustworthy painter will walk you through every step, answer questions honestly, and follow through on every promise.
That’s what we do at Black Mountain Painting. From residential interiors to log home staining and commercial exteriors, our team brings professionalism, experience, and integrity to every project.
Final Notes On Picking A Good Painter
Finding a good painter doesn’t have to be overwhelming when you know what to look for. From checking reviews and licenses to understanding materials and craftsmanship, the right painter should bring professionalism, experience, and pride to every job. At Black Mountain Painting, we’ve built our reputation across Spearfish, Deadwood, Lead, Sturgis, and the greater Black Hills by delivering consistent, high-quality results for homeowners and businesses alike. Whether you need an interior refresh, exterior repaint, or log home staining, our team combines skill, reliability, and honest communication to make your project simple from start to finish.
Ready to find the right painter for your home or business? Contact Black Mountain Painting today for a free estimate and discover why we’re one of the top-rated painting contractors in the Black Hills.
Frequently Asked Questions About Finding a Good Painter
1. How do I find a reliable painter near me?
To find a reliable painter, start by asking for recommendations from friends, neighbors, or local paint supply stores. Research each company online and read verified reviews on Google, Yelp, or Facebook. A dependable painter will have a strong reputation, clear communication, and examples of past work that demonstrate quality and consistency.
2. What should I ask before hiring a painter?
Before hiring a painter, ask questions about their experience, insurance, and licensing. Request a detailed written estimate that includes surface preparation, materials, number of coats, and timeline. It’s also smart to ask about warranty terms and how they handle unexpected issues or weather delays during a project.
3. How can I tell if a painter is professional?
Professional painters are punctual, organized, and transparent about their process. They use high-quality materials, protect surrounding areas from splatter, and keep their workspace clean. A professional will communicate clearly from start to finish, provide written documentation, and ensure you’re satisfied before completing the job.
4. What should a professional painting estimate include?
A professional painting estimate should include a full breakdown of the project scope: surface preparation, primer use, paint brands, number of coats, labor hours, and cleanup. It should also outline payment terms, start and completion dates, and any warranty information. Detailed, written estimates help avoid surprises later.
5. How much does it usually cost to hire a painter?
Painting costs vary depending on location, project size, and materials used. On average, homeowners spend $2 to $6 per square foot for professional interior or exterior painting. The best way to determine an accurate price is to request multiple written estimates from local contractors for comparison.
6. How do I make sure the paint job lasts?
A lasting paint job depends on proper preparation, quality materials, and skilled application. Surfaces should be cleaned, sanded, and primed before painting. Two coats of premium paint applied under the right temperature and humidity conditions will ensure durability and prevent peeling or fading over time.
7. Why is it better to hire a local painter?
Local painters are often more familiar with climate conditions, building materials, and community standards in your area. They can recommend paints and finishes that perform best in local weather. Hiring locally also supports small businesses and provides easier access to follow-up service or maintenance if needed.